Jump to Content

Not Fade Away - Reissue Review from Issue #59 Sept-Oct 2005

"5" Royales

It's Hard But It's Fair: The King Hits And Rarities (Ace UK)

The “5″ Royales have grown in stature over the years, but they still haven’t been given the place in history they deserve, largely because of King Records’ shoddy treatment of their catalogue. In my opinion, of course, this is a dirty shame; the group counted among their fans Ray Charles, James Brown and the Shirelles, not to mention a teenage guitarist in Missouri named Steve Cropper.

Oh, and me: I’ve been wild about them ever since John Goddard, presiding genius and owner of Village Music in Mill Valley, California, handed me a copy of their Dedicated To You album and said “You ever heard them? You should.” I later wrote about them in Greil Marcus’ 1979 anthology Stranded, and even though none of the information in there was correct (which was sort of the point, although not intentionally), at least it got their name out there.

This is probably not the album to start with — there’s a Very Best Of on Collectables, although I can’t vouch for anything but its track listing — but it certainly has a lot of essential tracks, including quite a few that even I had never heard before.

In case you came in late, the “5″ Royales started as a gospel group, the Royal Sons, and went secular after their first couple of singles flopped. Scoring three hits on Apollo (“Laundromat Blues”, “Crazy Crazy Crazy” and “Baby Don’t Do It”), they switched to King, which was able to give them better exposure, and recorded there from 1954-58, though only two of the singles they recorded in that time ever bothered the charts: “Think” and “Dedicated To The One I Love”.

What the masses missed, the connoisseurs — musicians — picked up on. After all, who understood their fusion of gospel, blues and pop better than Ray Charles and James Brown (whose Famous Flames were also a former gospel group)? And if they were too bluesy for northern fans, they resonated with southern ones: many a southerner remembers standing agape as Lowman Pauling, their bass singer, guitarist and chief songwriter, led them through an athletic 20-minute version of “The Slummer The Slum” (a.k.a. “The Stompety Stomp”), interspersing the group’s insane dance routine with burning guitar solos from his low-slung Gibson Les Paul.

There’s lots of Lowman’s guitar here, and in fact this would be a perfect introduction to the group if it had included “Don’t Be Ashamed To Call My Name”, the only one of his showcases not on board. You can still marvel to “Say It” and “Think”, masterpieces of concision. I’ve often regretted never playing the former for Stevie Ray Vaughan, because the guitar is sort of concentrated Hendrix.

The “rarities” aspect of this disc isn’t as dire as it could be, although I was disconcerted to hear “I Need Your Lovin’ Baby”, which is, um, “Kumbaya”. But as the group gets more confident that it can draw on its gospel roots, even the obscurities get better, and by 1960′s “(Something Moves Me) Within My Heart” and “I’m With You”, they’re doing soul music, pure and simple.

Johnny and Eugene Tanner, the Royales’ two lead singers, are still alive, although they’re unlikely ever to be inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. They should be, of course, because this disc proves conclusively that they, along with Ray Charles, Sam Cooke, and a very few others, invented soul music. Someday the history books will have to admit that. I know, it’s hard, but it’s fair.

Enjoy the ND archives? Consider making a donation. Advertising helps defray our basic expenses, but doesn’t touch the over $150,000 invested to get this content online. Just $10 (or more!) from 15,000 of our fans and we will reach our goal. Thanks for your support.

Or send a check to: No Depression, PO Box 31332, Seattle, WA 98103

Discuss

Did you enjoy this article? Start a discussion about it, or find out what others are saying in the No Depression Community forum.

Join the Discussion »

Find out what's going on in roots music. Share concert photos and videos, learn about new artists, blog about the music you love.

Join the No Depression Community »

Originally Featured in Issue #59 Sept-Oct 2005

Buy our history before it’s gone!

Each issue is artfully designed and packed full of great photos that you don‘t get online. Visit the No Depression store to own a piece of history.

Visit the No Depression Store »


From the Blogs

  • The Last Time I Saw Gram Parsons
    By Bill Conrad (His Prep School Pal)

 Summer of 1969, I was in London when I saw a flyer advertising the Byrds at Royal Albert Hall. Melody Maker, the local music news, suggested that a few Beatles and Stones might attend. That was incentive enough for me.
  The Byrds took the stage and launched into "Turn, Turn, Turn."  Other than band leader Rog […]
  • Davina and the Vagabonds at Newcastle Cluny II
    The Cluny, Newcastle Thursday 17th May 2012 Alan Harrison One of my greatest pleasures is discovering new music any of its shapes and forms and tonight was a bit of a revelation as I had only ventured out of the house because there was nothing on TV. As the support act finished there were only about 30 people scattered around The Cluny and perhaps 75 were sc […]
  • Lee Ann Womack Helps Houston's Homeless
    As founder and president of Healthcare for the Homeless -- Houston (HHH), Dr. David Buck (left with country star Lee Ann Womack at First Lady's Luncheon, Washington, D.C) is a busy man. So busy, in fact, he was taken aback when his office got a voice message from U.S. Representative Gene Green's wife Helen saying that she would like Dr. Buck to att […]
  • TPR#88 Addam Scott - Interview and Music
    On episode 88 of the Taproot Music Show, Addam Scott, the musician, not the actor, talks to Calvin about his latest CD, San Diablo. He discusses the concept of conflict that runs through the CD and how he likes ““I like to move forward that contradiction and show the best of who we are as people and the worst of who we are as people.” He discusses his musica […]
  • Album Review: Denison Witmer - The Ones Who Wait
    I’m going to confess that despite his fifteen year career in music,  I only discovered Asthmatic Kitty artist Denison Witmer last month when his ninth and latest CD The Ones Who Wait landed on my doormat, writes Neonfiller.com's Joe Lepper. Listening to the album I can see why he has been the anonymous bridesmaid but never the bride for so long. He can […]
  • Guest Blog: Roots Music in Portland, Maine
    
Hearth Music Guest Blog: Roots Music 
in Portland, ME
by Melissa Rae Cohen We've got a special guest blog today from travel writer Melissa Rae Cohen, writing all the way from Portland, Maine about the great roots music in her hometown! I grew up in a very musical environment. My father and grandfather used to sit… […]

Shop Amazon by clicking through this logo to support NoDepression.com. We get a percentage of every purchase you make!


Subscribe To the No Depression Newsletter

Subscribe to the No Depression Newsletter