Jump to Content

Welcome! You’re browsing the No Depression Archives

No Depression has been the foremost journalistic authority on roots music for well over a decade, publishing 75 issues from 1995 to 2008. No Depression ceased publishing magazines in 2008 and took to the web. We have made the contents of those issues accessible online via this extensive archive and also feature a robust community website with blogs, photos, videos, music, news, discussion and more.

Close This

Column from web archive February 16, 2009

Swingin' west with Wills, Willie, the Wheel, and Wexler

I have to make a musical confession: Before I spent ten years in Texas, there were two genres where I had a deaf spot – or whatever you call the aural equivalent of a blind spot. One was jazz-rock fusion. The other was western swing.

And though the hybrids were poles apart, I resisted both for similar reasons: They seemed to dilute the strengths of music that I loved in a purer form. Jazz-rock fusion was showoff stuff, lacking the maturity and emotional depth of real jazz and the primal power of real rock, offering instead complexity for complexity’s sake.

As for western swing, I would have rather listened to real Texas country like Lefty Frizzell’s or real swing like Benny Goodman’s than the hokey hybrid purveyed by Bob Wills & His Texas Playboys. If I loved “Bob Wills Is Still The King”, which I did and do, it was because it sounded like a Waylon Jennings song rather than a Bob Wills song.

I guess I got acculturated, as Texans would never say. Old dancehalls filled with dancers who were almost as old softened me up. So did Don Walser, George Strait and Lyle Lovett’s Large Band. Asleep At The Wheel, still carrying the torch of western swing, began to sound like more than a novelty anachronism to me. And the great fiddler Johnny Gimble provided a living link to the Wills legacy.

The music of fiddler/bandleader Bob Wills remains so deeply imprinted within the lifeblood of Texas that resistance was futile. Wills’ western swing isn’t a diluted hybrid but a radical departure, distinctly different from both Frizzell and Goodman, as much a part of the state’s unique cultural dynamic as wide open spaces and homemade salsa. Denying the enduring appeal of Wills’ music is like denying oxygen or gravity.

But I’d like to think that even if I’d never moved to Texas or heard any western swing, I’d be blown away by the new ten-disc set The Tiffany Transcriptions. Throughout these mid-1940s recordings, earmarked for radio rather than retail, the band doesn’t simply swing, it smokes. This is music that revels in its iconoclasm. This is a jazz band with steel guitar, a blues band with two or three fiddles, a country band with wilder electric guitar than rockabilly would soon deliver. It’s a band that can draw from the repertoire of Benny Goodman and Woody Guthrie, Count Basie and Jimmie Rodgers. It’s equally at home with “Red River Valley” and “Take the ‘A’ Train”.

Such refusal to respect categorical boundaries is one of the main things I love about Texas music. While each of these ten discs is a delight – and the last, featuring the vocals of the McKinney Sisters, is a particular revelation – disc two in particular shows not only the band’s reach but the depth of its legacy. Framed by signature tunes – opening with the one-two punch of “Take Me Back to Tulsa” and “Faded Love” and closing with a definitive “San Antonio Rose” – the disc encompasses “Stay A Little Longer”, later to be a Willie Nelson perennial; “Ida Red”, the inspiration for Chuck Berry’s “Maybellene” (and thus a cornerstone of rock ‘n’ roll); “Cotton Eyed Joe”, soon to be the national anthem of Texas dancehalls; and “Cherokee Maiden”, one of the band’s many dips into the classic Cindy Walker songbook.


Samples from disc two of The Tiffany Transcriptions

Because the recordings weren’t limited by the time restrictions of the dominant 78 rpm vinyl format of the day, the band has the leeway it needs to stretch out and let loose. Pianist Millard Kelso, guitarists Junior Barnard and Eldon Shamblin, and mandolinist Tiny Moore are among the many stalwarts who take full advantage. As steel guitarist Herb Remington writes on the sleeve to disc four, “I think music fans, not just Bob Wills fans, will truly enjoy these sounds of a time when music was melody, and instrumentalists were recognized for their individual styles.” Listening to these sessions is like being in the liveliest Texas dancehall with the hottest band in the land: Stay all night, stay a little longer.

If further testament to the enduring appeal of western swing were necessary, the release of Willie And The Wheel celebrates a kindred-spirit teaming of Willie Nelson and Asleep At The Wheel that brings out the best in both. It’s also a revelation, as horns add a Dixieland feel to some of the arrangements, bringing the music closer to New Orleans than Texas, and Wheel alumnus Floyd Domino graces the sessions on piano.


Samples from Willie And The Wheel

Nelson sounds as much in his element as he does with his own band. While drawing from some of the same material as The Tiffany Transcriptions, this is more than another Wills tribute, widening the net to acknowledge the seminal influence of Wills’ former bandmate, Milton Brown. The project apparently was first mentioned more than 35 years ago, when the late Jerry Wexler helped re-launch Nelson’s career (and put Austin on the musical map). He’d subsequently suggested to the Wheel’s Ray Benson a bunch of western swing songs that he thought it would be perfect for Nelson to sing.

The duet by Nelson and Benson on “Right Or Wrong” highlights this disc in a manner that would have fit fine on Nelson’s classic Stardust. But the whole album sounds closer to classic Nelson than to the throwaway collaborations that have marked too much of his career. This is a labor of love, the love of Willie for the Wheel and vice versa, and the love of all for western swing.

As for jazz-rock fusion, I still think Charlie Watts is a far greater drummer than Billy Cobham.


Promo video for Willie And The Wheel

Enjoy the ND archives? Consider making a donation. Advertising helps defray our basic expenses, but doesn’t touch the over $150,000 invested to get this content online. Just $10 (or more!) from 15,000 of our fans and we will reach our goal. Thanks for your support.

Or send a check to: No Depression, PO Box 31332, Seattle, WA 98103

Discuss

Did you enjoy this article? Start a discussion about it, or find out what others are saying in the No Depression Community forum.

Join the Discussion »

Find out what's going on in roots music. Share concert photos and videos, learn about new artists, blog about the music you love.

Join the No Depression Community »

Buy our history before it’s gone!

Each issue is artfully designed and packed full of great photos that you don‘t get online. Visit the No Depression store to own a piece of history.

Visit the No Depression Store »


From the Blogs

  • Enter to win a signed copy of 'Steve Earle: The Warner Bros. Years' box set
    Ever since his 1986 debut (and, in some ways, even before that), Steve Earle has been one of the most prolific and distinctive singer-songwriters on the Amerciana/alt/country/rock scene. His 15 studio albums have encompassed political protest music, bluegrass, rock and roll, Townes Van Zandt covers, and just flat-out, darn-good genre-defying music. His work […]
  • When politics met Americana in 1976
    One of the pleasures of being of a certain age is that you can literally rack up decades of seeing great musicians and attending gigs of all shapes and sizes. A recent BBC documentary about The Eagles jarred my memory about one such event in (gulp) 1976.  I was a Brit newbie in America and was taken to a political fund raiser for then (and now) California Go […]
  • Father's Day: Songs About Dad
    This is the weekend where we examine the impact great fathers have made upon history.  From the Bible, where the landscape is littered with the actions of fathers.  Who could forget the long walk Abraham and his son took in Genesis?  Adam, the first father, raised a fine bunch of stand-up children.  And what about the Big Father himself -- Jesus' daddy […]
  • Album Review: The Human Experience ft. Rising Appalachia - Soul Visions
    The Human Experience, an artist I’ve come to know much about recently, will be releasing a new album on Monday, featuring sisters Leah and Chloe Smith of Rising Appalachia. The album is called Soul Visions, and, upon listening, truly resonates as the vision of three creative souls collaborating to produce something highly elevated. David Block, the mind behi […]
  • Remembering Rory Gallagher: "The People's Guitarist"
    I've always remembered a great line from a wonderful little film called The Commitments, which tells the story of a ragtag assortment of Dubliners who form a soul band. A character named Jimmy Rabbitte says, "The Irish are the blacks of Europe." To me, that says a lot. Like African Americans, the Irish have lived The Blues for centuries. And i […]
  • Billy Bragg, Union Chapel, Islington (London, UK. 5th June 2013)
    Really, all is need to tellyou is that for the second encore Billy Bragg played the whole of his debut album LIFE’S A RIOT WITH SPY VS SPY for you to understand what an amazing show this was! In thirty years, Bragg has travelled the path from angry young man, to political activist to national treasure and his live performances are among the best you’ll ever […]

Shop Amazon by clicking through this logo to support NoDepression.com. We get a percentage of every purchase you make!


Subscribe To the No Depression Newsletter

Subscribe to the No Depression Newsletter